Don’t be fooled: All forms of smoking can kill
Smoking is a gamble with your life, regardless of the device you use. There are no safe alternatives, whether it is vaping or smoking a hookah…they all have unique health risks that could shorten your life expectancy significantly.
Whether you are smoking a traditional cigarette or using one of the thought-to-be “safer” alternatives like vaping or a hookah pipe, you are putting your health at serious risk and increasing your chances of premature death. This is the undeniable truth that many fail to grasp, explains Ingrid Bame, Project Coordinator at the National Council Against Smoking (NCAS).
Concerning trends
Bame notes that there has been a worrisome increase in smoking in South Africa in recent years.
“The first Global Adult Tobacco Survey (GATS) in South Africa was conducted by the South African Medical Research Council (SAMRC) in 2021 which indicated the prevalence among adults aged 15 and older was sitting at 29,4%. This is partly attributed to the rising popularity of new products like vapes and hookahs among younger people.”
A University of Cape Town study involving 25,000 high school learners revealed that 16.8% are current e-cigarette smokers, while only 2% smoke traditional cigarettes. “This clearly shows a high uptake of smoking, specifically with vapes and e-cigarettes, which are heavily marketed and come in appealing flavours, making them attractive to the youth,” Bame elaborates.
Proposed bill offers a ray of hope
The proposed Tobacco Products and Electronic Delivery Systems Control Bill offers a crucial framework to address this growing problem. Apart from banning smoking in all indoor and outdoor areas and introducing plain packaging with pictorial health warnings on all tobacco products, it will impose strict regulations on the marketing and sale of e-cigarettes for the first time.
Debunking the “safer” myth
The NCAS firmly rejects the notion that vaping and hookah are safe alternatives to traditional cigarettes. “When these new products entered the market, they were often misportrayed as less harmful and even as cessation tools,” Bame clarifies. “However, the marketing strategies, particularly the appealing flavours and sleek packaging, are clearly designed to attract a younger audience. The tobacco industry uses social media influencers and digital media creators to associate these products with a certain lifestyle and social status, luring in a new generation of smokers who become addicted due to the high nicotine levels and other harmful chemicals.”
The vaping fallacy
Despite the perception of being safer, vaping carries its own set of significant health risks.
“Vapes often have variable and sometimes very high nicotine levels, making them highly addictive, especially for young people whose brains are still developing. This can also lead to mental health challenges like depression and anxiety,” Bame says.
She also highlights respiratory issues: “Vaping is linked to lung infections and other respiratory problems. A particularly concerning condition is ‘popcorn lung’ (bronchiolitis obliterans), a serious and irreversible lung disease caused by chemicals like diacetyl found in some vape flavourings.” While specific data on the development timeline of popcorn lung is unavailable, the potential for such severe and irreversible damage underscores the dangers of vaping.
The misconception that vaping is not addictive is dangerously false. “Vaping products contain nicotine, the same highly addictive substance found in traditional cigarettes,” Bame stresses. “In some cases, vapes can even have higher nicotine concentrations, leading to quicker and stronger addiction.”
Nicotine affects the brain’s reward system, creating a dependency. When someone tries to quit, they experience withdrawal symptoms like irritability, anxiety, and intense cravings. This makes it very difficult to break the cycle of addiction, regardless of whether it’s through traditional cigarettes or vapes.
The developing brains and bodies of children and adolescents are particularly vulnerable to the harms of vaping. “Nicotine exposure during these critical years can have long-lasting negative consequences on brain development, affecting attention, learning, mood, and impulse control,” warns Bame. “It can also increase the risk of future addiction to other substances.”
Furthermore, the aerosol from vapes contains harmful chemicals and tiny particles that can damage young lungs. The long-term effects are still being studied, but early evidence suggests increased risks of respiratory illnesses and potential cardiovascular problems.
Life years lost
Research has consistently shown the devastating impact of smoking on life expectancy. “On average, smokers lose about 10 to 11 years of life compared to non-smokers,” Bame states. “More specifically, each cigarette smoked is estimated to cut off around 11 minutes of life.”
While quitting at any point offers benefits, the sooner someone stops, the better their chances of recovering some lost years and improving their overall quality of life.
Hookah harms
The social aspect of hookah smoking often masks its significant health risks. “Hookah smoke contains high levels of carbon monoxide due to the burning charcoal, as well as nicotine from the flavoured molasses,” Bame explains. “Contrary to popular belief, the water does not filter out these harmful toxins.”
Hookah smoke contains many of the same toxic chemicals found in cigarette smoke, including heavy metals and carcinogens. A typical 45-minute to one-hour hookah session can expose users to the equivalent of smoking 100 cigarettes in terms of smoke volume. Sharing hookah pipes also poses risks of infectious diseases like tuberculosis, herpes, and hepatitis.
Why people smoke
Despite widespread knowledge of its harms, people still initiate and continue to smoke due to a complex interplay of factors. Beyond marketing, psychosocial factors play a significant role. “Peer pressure, the desire to fit in, and the perception that smoking can help cope with stress are major drivers, especially among adolescents,” Bame explains. Nicotine addiction then becomes a powerful force in maintaining continued use.
The quitting challenge
Quitting tobacco use is difficult due to the highly addictive nature of nicotine. “However, the challenge goes beyond just the physical addiction,” Bame notes. “Smoking often becomes deeply ingrained in daily routines and social activities, creating strong behavioural and psychological dependencies.”
Certain places, people, or emotional states can trigger intense cravings. The fear of withdrawal symptoms and the lack of adequate support also contribute significantly to the difficulty of quitting.
You can quit!
The NCAS offers various programmes and support services to assist individuals in their journey to quit smoking. This includes a telephonic and WhatsApp quit-line (011 720 3145 / 072 766 4812) where people can receive advice and support from trained Quit Officers.
While specific success rates for these programmes can vary, Bame emphasises that having support significantly increases the chances of successful cessation compared to trying to quit alone. The NCAS also collaborates with other organisations and advocates for policies that create a supportive environment for quitting.
“The most critical and urgent message we want to convey to South Africans is that all forms of smoking are dangerous and carry serious health risks. The deceptive marketing of vaping and hookah as safer alternatives must be debunked. These products contain harmful chemicals and are often highly addictive, posing significant threats, especially to our youth.”
She urges the public to prioritise their health by choosing a smoke-free life. “Support the Tobacco Control Bill, educate yourselves and your families about the dangers of all smoking products, and reach out for help if you or someone you know wants to quit. A smoke-free South Africa is a healthier South Africa.”